Fake Google reviews: what to do when you find one, and why buying them backfires
How to tell a genuinely fake review from a negative one, how to report it to Google, what 1,403 real profiles in Catania show about a credible review profile, and what buying reviews risks.
By Valerio Aloi · Published: November 12, 2026
Reviews matter: to customers and, now, to the AI tools that recommend businesses. In my study on local SEO and AI, profiles with 50 to 199 reviews were cited by at least two AI engines in 33% of cases, those with fewer than 10 in 9%. That creates two temptations: making negative reviews disappear and buying positive ones. Reporting a review that is genuinely fake is legitimate; buying positive ones is not. Here are both, with the numbers on what a genuine profile looks like.
A note: this is a practical guide, not legal advice. For a specific case, talk to a lawyer.
Before you report: is it really fake?
Many owners report genuine reviews they simply dislike, and Google leaves them up. Before reporting, ask yourself:
- Was this person ever your customer? Check the name, date and service in your records, invoices and bookings.
- Does the text describe something real? A service you don’t offer, or a different location, are strong signals.
- Are there several identical or serial reviews? Same text, same day, newly created profiles.
- Does the author have an interest? A competitor, a former employee, someone you are in a dispute with.
- Is there abuse or personal information? Those break the policies even when the customer is real.
If the answer to the first question is “yes, they were a customer” and there is no abuse, the review stays. There, reply instead of reporting.
Which reviews Google removes
Google removes reviews that break its policies, not reviews you dislike. Its help centre is explicit: don’t report a review just because you disagree with it. Valid reasons include:
- Spam and fake reviews: people who were never customers, reviews in bulk, copied text.
- Off-topic: comments about politics, the news or a different business.
- Conflict of interest: a competitor reviewing you, or a former employee.
- Profane, offensive or discriminatory content, harassment or someone’s personal information.
A negative but genuine review from a real customer, with no abuse, stays. There the best move is a calm, factual reply: future customers read it too.
How to report a Google review, step by step
From your Business Profile:
- Open your Google Business Profile (search your business name while signed in, or go to business.google.com).
- Select Read reviews.
- Next to the review, select the report icon.
- Pick the reason (for example «Spam» or «Conflict of interest») and submit the report.
From the Review Management Tool, which is also where you follow the report’s status: sign in with the account that manages the profile, pick the business, then «Report a new review». The status tells you whether a decision is still pending, whether the report was reviewed and no violation was found, or whether the review was removed. The check usually takes a few days.
If the review isn’t removed you get one appeal, from the same tool, covering up to 10 reviews. So report with the right reason from the start and, in the appeal, add the context that proves the violation (for example, that this person was never your customer).
What to prepare before the appeal, because you only get one:
- The link to the review and a screenshot showing the date and the author’s profile.
- Proof they weren’t a customer: no matching name in your records, no booking on that date.
- The Google policy it breaks, in one line.
- A single appeal covering all the related reviews (up to 10), not one at a time.
What a genuine profile looks like: the Catania numbers
For the local SEO and AI study I collected the Google Maps profiles of 20 trades in Catania, Sicily. For this guide I recalculated the review data: 1,561 distinct profiles, 1,403 with at least one review and 158 (10%) with none. The median is 37 reviews per profile.
A 5.0 rating belongs to small profiles.
| Reviews | Profiles | Rated 5.0 | Rated 4.8 or more |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fewer than 10 | 360 | 69% | 73% |
| 10-49 | 438 | 34% | 63% |
| 50-199 | 347 | 23% | 61% |
| 200 or more | 258 | 10% | 35% |
The 504 profiles rated 5.0 have a median of 10 reviews; all the others, 63. A 5.0 with few reviews is the norm and says nothing improper. As reviews accumulate, the rating settles between 4.5 and 4.9.
A profile with volume always has some negative reviews. Across 318,848 reviews on profiles with at least 50 reviews (605 profiles), 75.5% are 5-star, 13.2% 4-star, 4.8% 3-star, 2.1% 2-star and 4.4% 1-star. Only 69 of 605 profiles (11%) have no 1-3 star review at all; the median share of 1-3 star reviews is 5.9%.
Two things follow for the owner. A few negative reviews are normal and help credibility: reply calmly rather than trying to remove them all. And a spike of five-star reviews with no text and no negatives is the opposite of a genuine profile, which is why bought reviews are often the first ones to be filtered.
Limits: Catania data collected in October 2026, on local business profiles. The displayed rating is rounded to one decimal, so “5.0” includes 4.95-4.99.
Fake Google reviews: what Google does to buyers
Buying reviews, or offering anything in exchange for one, is «fake engagement» under Google’s policies. The ban covers any incentive, whether the review is positive or negative: discounts, freebies, gift cards, loyalty points, prize draws. Asking only happy customers for reviews is banned too. When Google finds this, it can apply three restrictions to the profile:
- no new reviews for a period of time;
- existing reviews hidden for a period of time;
- a public warning on the profile telling customers that fake reviews were removed.
The owner is notified by email and can appeal. But the damage, especially the warning, is visible to everyone.
Are fake reviews illegal?
- United States: the FTC’s rule on consumer reviews and testimonials, in force since October 21, 2024, bans fake reviews, buying positive or negative reviews, undisclosed insider reviews and review suppression. For knowing violations the FTC can seek civil penalties of up to $51,744 per violation (the 2024 figure, adjusted for inflation each year).
- European Union: since the Omnibus directive, submitting or commissioning fake reviews is an unfair commercial practice in every member state. Italy went further in 2026 with a specific law for restaurants and tourism.
There is also the practical problem: bought reviews are often the first ones Google’s filters remove, and a sudden spike of text-free five-star reviews draws the wrong kind of attention.
A real penalty
Penalties aren’t theoretical. In Italy, with ruling no. 31485 of March 4, 2025, the competition authority (AGCM) fined a company €10,000 for selling reviews and interactions on social media and online platforms that could not be traced to real consumer experiences (FoodTimes).
How to reply to a review you can’t remove
For genuine but negative reviews, three lines are enough:
- Thank them and name the issue, without defensiveness: “Thanks for flagging the wait on Thursday.”
- One piece of context, if needed, with no accusations.
- A way to resolve it, outside the profile.
Never write details about a customer (appointments, treatments, amounts): your reply is public.
What works instead of shortcuts
The method that works is boring but holds up: ask every customer for a review right after the job, with a direct link to your profile, and reply to all of them. How to create the link or QR code, and how many reviews you really need according to the study, is in how many Google reviews do you need. The rest of the profile work is in the Google Business Profile guide.
Google reviews FAQ
Is a profile with no negative reviews suspicious?
Not necessarily, but it is rare. Among the Catania profiles with at least 50 reviews, 9 in 10 have at least one 1-3 star review, and the median share of 1-3 star reviews is 5.9%.
Is a 5.0 rating a good sign?
Often it just means few reviews, not a perfect business: among the Catania profiles, 69% of those with fewer than 10 reviews show 5.0, against 10% of those with more than 200.
Can I get a negative Google review removed?
Only if it breaks Google’s policies: spam or fake, off-topic, conflict of interest, offensive content or personal information. A negative but genuine review stays; reply to it calmly and on the merits.
How long does Google take to remove a reported review?
The check usually takes a few days. You follow the status in the Review Management Tool; if the review stays, you get one appeal covering up to 10 reviews.
Are fake reviews illegal?
In the US, the FTC rule in force since October 21, 2024 bans fake and bought reviews, with civil penalties of up to $51,744 per violation for knowing violators (2024 figure). In the EU fake reviews are an unfair commercial practice. This is not legal advice.
Can I offer a discount in exchange for a review?
No. Under Google’s policies any incentive tied to a review, positive or negative, is fake engagement, and the FTC rule also restricts incentives conditioned on the review’s sentiment.
What happens if Google finds fake reviews on my profile?
It can block new reviews, hide existing ones for a period and show a public warning that fake reviews were removed. You can appeal.
Want your profile checked?
A free audit of your Google profile, reviews and website, to see what keeps you off the map.